Saturday, 3 October 2015

Sentences: Complete and Incomplete Sentences

A Sentence - What is it and what makes it complete?
What is a sentence?  You might have been taught that, at a basic level, a complete sentence consists of a subject, verb and object.  However, this definition is too simplistic.

I (subject) go (verb or action word) to the market (objective of the action `go').

Therefore, in the simplest sense, it is correct to say in a sentence there is a subject, verb and object.

However, as Man is complex so is language.

I exist.

This is also a sentence, but there is no object; there is only the subject, `I', and the verb `exist'.  Therefore, it would be more instructive to think of a complete sentence as one that includes a complete thought.

A complete sentence is one that is able to convey one's thought completely.

Take a look at the following and ask yourself which of these include a complete thought and which don't.

Even though I studied hard.
I tried my best to persuade her.
The mighty waves thundered.
While the game was on.
Waiting at the sidelines.

The incomplete sentences are the following since they do not include complete thoughts:

Even though I studied hard.
While the game was on.
Waiting at the sidelines.

The use of `even though', `while' and `waiting' indicates that the writer has more information to disclose.

  1. I studied hard but something contrary to what would normally happen took place. What was it? We are not told.  However, if we add that information, as shown in the next sentence, then the sentence will be complete since the `full' thought is offered to the reader.  Even though I studied hard, I failed in the exam.
  2. Again, something happened `while the game was on'. Therefore, to complete the sentence, I could add: A man ran onto the pitch while the game was on.
  3. We have no idea what to make of the `waiting at the sidelines'. Waiting is a gerund, that is, a word ending in `ing'.  If I were to convert the given example to the following: Waiting at the sidelines is a bad idea, then the `waiting at the sidelines' becomes a gerund phrase, that is, it becomes a noun - the subject of the verb `is'.


The remaining two, which are repeated below, are complete sentences since they complete the thoughts that need to be expressed.

I tried my best to persuade her.

The mighty waves thundered.

Sunday, 13 September 2015

Suggested answers to exercise on Semi-colon and comma


     ;    and the    ,    


The answers to the exercise on the semi-colon and comma that was given in an earlier post is now available on The Pear Tree Blog. If you would like to check your answers or if you would like to have us look at your explanations for why you chose, or did not choose, to include the commas and semi-colons, please do write to us at admin1@thepeartree.info

Monday, 7 September 2015

Punctuation: The Comma

The comma has a few uses but here, I am going on to concentrate on just one, the one that many miss.  I have noticed when I teach children or adults that few know about the use of the comma to separate the main idea from elaborations or added details.  This is, actually, a useful device since it helps the reader to pause, take in the added details and at the same time, pinpoint the main idea that is expressed by the writer.

Take for example:


I went to the market, which I frequent, to buy groceries.

The main idea: I went to the market to buy groceries.
Added detail: which I frequent - this piece of information is not important but it gives the reader a better picture of the market in relation to the writer.

Another example is given below:


Although I put in a lot of effort, my entry was not accepted.

The main idea: My entry was not accepted.  That is the gist of what the writer wants to get across, but the writer also wants to give you the reason for, perhaps, feeling disappointed at the non-acceptance.  Hence, one gets the subsidiary, or secondary point, which is: Although I put in a lot of effort

Have a look at the third example offered below:

We were among the first at the concert theatre.  Hence, since it was free-seating, we had our choice of seats.
`Hence' is a transitional word.  It shows the relationship, or link, between the two ideas, namely, `We were among the first at the concert theatre' and `we had our choice of seats'.  It is an elaboration and not quite a part of the main idea found in the second sentence.  Similarly, `since it was free-seating' is also an elaboration and is not part of the main sentence or thought.

Now, attempt the following exercise which has the commas and semi-colons removed. Insert these where appropriate.  The answers, with explanations for some for these answers, will be available on the The Pear Tree website on Sept 10.


Jane and Peter in the hope that they will find Jane's missing wallet went to the mall.  They retraced the steps that they took while at the mall the previous day however they could not find the wallet.  Jane was distressed at having lost her wallet it had sentimental value for her as well.  Her grandmother had given her the beaded wallet for her birthday but now that her grandmother was no more she wanted that wallet more than ever in memory of her grandmother.  Jane sat on the stairs going from the lower floor to the second floor of the mall she burst into tears.  Just then a security guard walked up her she saw the familiar blue beads peeking out from the gaps in between his curled fingers.  She looked up expectantly at the man who was tall and stern-looking she could feel her heart beat faster and faster as he advanced.

Wednesday, 2 September 2015

The Story about the Semi-Colon (Continued)


The explanation below was taken from the earlier post.  Can you explain why the commas, semi-colons and full-stops were used in each of the sentences?


  1. You, my cousin, in reality helps to make a sentence clear and you also show how two sentences, or complete thoughts, are actually related to each other. 
  2. (1) is a complete thought. 
  3. (2) is another complete thought but it is related to (1); hence, it shows that while the earlier idea in (1) can stand on its own, the writer is not done with the idea. 
  4. He or she wants to continue by adding another, related, idea to it.

  1. The commas are used here to elaborate on the `you'.  Who is the `you'?  What is within the commas (`my cousin') reveals who the `you' is, and it also helps to separate it from the main idea so as to demonstrate that this is an extra, or added, information. The same goes for the `or complete thoughts'.  The commas allows one to relate it to what comes before, namely the `sentences', thus, demonstrating that `complete thoughts' are the same as `sentences' and are included to stress the fact that they mean the same.
  2. There is only one idea here and the writer wants to express just that one idea, hence, the full-stop is used at the end.
  3. The idea that comes after the semi-colon is related to the idea that comes before.  The second part, after the semi-colon, is there for further explain what is meant by the first idea contained in the complete thought that comes before the semi-colon.
  4. Again, the word `related' found within the commas is an added detail, to further describe the `another'.

Hope the above explanations are easy to follow and that you have understood the purpose of commas, semi-colons and full-stops (or periods).  If you would like to continue on your journey in better understanding the various English Language usages, join our online lessons.  Tell us your needs and we will tailor-make the lessons to meet those needs.  We can be reached at learnenglishonline201@gmail.com

Thursday, 13 August 2015

The story about the Semi-Colon

Have you ever been stumped by the different purposes that the comma, semi-colon and the full-stop, or period, serve in expressing a writer's intent? Read the following short dialogue that these three cousins had and you will find out more about their close relationship. 

(Big Cousin Brother, Full-Stop, chanced upon Semi-Colon and her young sibling, Comma having an interesting conversation at the coffee-shop, just down the street from the block of flats they lived in.  He decided to join in.)

Comma: Hey, Col, I never said you are not important!
Semi-Colon: Oh yeah?! Then, what does it mean when you accuse me of confusing people... that, that, people don't like to use me. That they rather use you than...
Comma: Oh, come on, Col. I am just stating a fact. People find me less confusing, but that doesn't mean you are not important. Both of us are!

(Just then, Full-Stop drew out a chair at their table and plopped down with a heavy sigh.)

Full-Stop: Really?! You gals are at it again? Look, I am going to do what I was born to do - put a full-stop to all this nonsense right here and now! So, listen carefully because this is the last time I am going to do it, period! Col, my Semi-Colon dude, you've got the best of both worlds since you've both me and Comma in you. Just take a look below:
.  +  ,  =  ;  

I am the one that completes the sentences and allows the reader or speaker to pause a bit longer than when Comma comes in. Humans can't go on and on; they need time to take a breather, short and long, and to process multiple ideas. Take for instance the following:

I went to the Gardens by the Bay. 

The full-stop here indicates that one piece of information is given for you to process at one go. The sentence, or one complete thought, has ended here.

I went to the Gardens by the Bay (1), and, while visiting the conservatories (2), saw many species of plant-life (3). 

Here, our dear Comma plays the important role of separating the added information found in (2)  from the two main ideas, which are found in (1) and (3)

Now, let's come to you, Semi-Colon. 

I went to the Gardens by the Bay (1); I consider it a learning adventure during which I came across so many different kinds of plants and trees (2). 

You, my cousin, in reality helps to make a sentence clear and you also show how two sentences, or complete thoughts, are actually related to each other. (1) is a complete thought. (2) is another complete thought but it is related to (1); hence, it shows that while the earlier idea in (1) can stand on its own, the writer is not done with the idea. He or she wants to continue by adding another, related, idea to it.


Just go over the last explanation more carefully and try to figure out why the commas, semi-colon and full-stops, or periods, were used. We will provide an explanation in the next post.



Tuesday, 4 August 2015

Answers (Reading Comprehension and Critical Thinking)

Below is a photo of the bird that inspired me to pen the poem, that I had included in the earlier post, and which I am reproducing below.

My Feathered Friend

I spied thee, my feathered friend,
Pecking furiously at thy perceived foe,
Thy hard beak pounding at thy reflected self;
It too had its head thrust to the mirrored pane
With its chocolate-hued wings spread from its dark body
And red-rimmed eyes staring, unblinking, unyielding;
Aye, thy foe, postured much like thyself, was ready for battle,

Returning peck for peck with like ferocity, like enmity.


Words, if used appropriately, have the power to create pictures in your mind. Words such as `saw', `hitting', `bent forward' and `standing' only convey a general idea. There is very little that one can draw from such words; there is a lack of symbolism, emotions and/or characteristics of the protagonist.

o   The word `spied' gives one the idea that the one being viewed is unaware of being watched.
o   `Pounding' displays a greater force being exerted than a mere `hitting'. Here, one may view the action as aggressive and hence, the bird could be seen as being angry or upset.
o   `Thrust' is a beautiful word that indicates a deliberate, intentioned, attempt to push the head forward. This action allows the reader to appreciate the fact that the bird is purposely looking closely at the window pane, observing closely something that has caught its attention. It gives the bird `life' and it becomes an entity that can think, that can feel.
o    `Postured' gives one an idea that the bird has a certain attitude, a certain bearing that indicates a specific emotion. In this case, based on context, we know that the posture is aggressive, that the bird is positioning itself in a way that shows it is ready to fight.

  •  What is the feeling that the bird is experiencing? Why is it feeling that way?
The bird sees another bird in the `mirrored pane' and thinks it is a foe, and hence, it feels hatred, leading to its rage against the supposed foe. It is hostile toward the bird and hence, is ready to fight it
  • Is the feeling justified?
No, it is not, since what it sees in the `mirrored pane' is a reflection of itself. There is no other bird there; it is actually seeing itself on the other side.
  • Can the bird's reaction be extended to the human experience?
Yes, very often, we project our feelings of animosity toward non-existing entities. We create these entities in our mind, imagining a foe where there is none. We work ourselves up in a fury when there is no reason to be furious. These entities, if we look closely, are really very much like ourselves.
  • What lesson may we, as humans, derive from the bird's reaction?

The reflection of the bird in the mirror need not be an image of a foe, but it could be a reflection of the negative feelings a person may have, stemming from prejudice, arrogance or a sense of insecurity. These feelings are meaningless and unproductive. We end up harming ourselves ultimately and all for nothing, since there is no real threat.

Monday, 20 July 2015

Reading Comprehension and Critical Thinking (Updated)

Read through the following poem. 

What do you get from reading the poem? 

  • What is it about? 
  • Is there a message? 
  • Can one extend the meaning to correlate it to human behaviour?
  • What is the use of imagery found in the poem?
  • What is the use of selected words in the poem?

My Feathered Friend
I spied thee, my feathered friend,
Pecking furiously at thy perceived foe,
Thy hard beak pounding at thy reflected self;
It too had its head thrust to the mirrored pane
With its chocolate-hued wings spread from its dark body
And red-rimmed eyes staring, unblinking, unyielding;
Aye, thy foe, postured much like thyself, was ready for battle,
Returning peck for peck with like ferocity, like enmity.

In the next post, suggested responses to the above questions will be forwarded. Do take the time to come up with your own responses for answers can differ from individual to individual and there need not be a `correct' answer.

If you would like us to take a look at your responses, do send them to us at admin1@thepeartree.info



Guiding Questions:

My `feathered friend', with references to being `feathered', and with a `beak' and `wings' would naturally be a bird. 


  • Thus, based on the other descriptions of the bird, what would be the colours that you would expect to see on the different parts of the bird's body. (An outline is given below for you to colour in the various hues adorning the bird.)



  • What are effects of using words such as: 
`spied' instead of `saw'; `pounding' instead of `hitting'; `thrust' instead of `bent forward'; `postured' instead of `standing'

  •  What is the feeling that the bird is experiencing? Why is it feeling that way?
  • Is the feeling justified?
  • Can the bird's reaction be extended to the human experience? Would some people react in a similar fashion?
  • What lesson may we, as humans, derive from the bird's reaction?